2023 First-Team
Catcher: Jared Chesak (Kewaskum A’s)
Infielders: Harry Steldt (Sheboygan A’s), Jalen Gellings (Kewaskum A’s), Brayden Pleau (Menasha Macs), James Bornick (Green Bay Blue Ribbons)
Utility: Chase Hanselman (Menasha Macs)
Outfielders: Sean Menzel (Kewaskum A’s), Landon Behring (Kewaskum A’s), Bennet Becker (Sheboygan A’s)
Pitchers: Brad Rindfleisch (Sheboygan A’s), Owen Deprez (Green Bay Blue Ribbons), Jack Grable (Menasha Macs)
2023 Second-Team
Infielders: Jimmy Jurgensen (Sheboygan A’s), Carson Krumrei (Appleton Legends), Tyler Pigeon (Appleton Legends)
Utility: Blake Wallenfang (Appleton Legends)
Pitchers: Dylan Davis (Sheboygan A’s), Jim Ziegler (Kewaskum A’s), Jake Sweet (Kewaskum A’s), Tanner Alsteen (Green Bay Blue Ribbons), Allen Leitner (Menasha Macs), Griffin Klein (Menasha Macs), Jason Jennerjohn (Appleton Legends)